When multiple bucks start circling around a "hot" doe, the trophy hunter is treated to one of the most exciting -- and potentially most productive -- events of the entire deer season. If this golden opportunity ever comes your way, here's how to play it right.
By Gordon Whittington
You don't always need to get mobile to take advantage of a whitetail breeding party. The group of Illinois bucks and does that included this non-typical moved close to the author's tree stand before daylight, then hung around long enough to end up with starring roles on North American Whitetail Television. Photo by Mike Clerkin.
In everyday life, showing up uninvited at a party is at best an uncouth move. But if the party you're crashing is one that features bucks and does acting upon their animal instincts, then I'd be the first to say barging right in is a fine idea.
Although you won't find it in any dictionary, a whitetail "breeding party" can be defined as two or more lustful bucks vying for the affections of one or more does. The scene is often one of chaos, by the standards of whitetail society, with multiple bucks, does and even fawns frantically interacting in a way not seen at any other time. Deer are running here and there, and for one of the few times in their lives, even the big bucks are paying far more attention to the other deer than to danger.
For reasons obvious to any experienced hunter, a breeding party is considered the Holy Grail of hunting scenarios. When you have multiple bucks on their feet in daylight, and they're focused on securing a mate, it can be a great hunting opportunity. The dream of being on the scene when this happens is what makes the avid trophy hunter long for the rut.
Unfortunately, several key factors often keep the dream from coming true. First, as we all know, real-world deer woods tend not to be overpopulated with bucks to start with. Also, by the time breeding kicks off, there usually has been enough hunting pressure to shut down daytime buck movement anyway. Even does have grown pretty leery of walking around in broad daylight by then.
In an out-of-whack herd, while you might see a breeding party at the classic time, there's actually a better chance of it at two other times. The first, chronologically, is the "false" rut that can occur a month or so prior to the primary breeding period. In most locations, this minor flurry of buck-doe interaction takes place in October, with the peak of breeding in November. Other relatively likely times to see a breeding party are the second or even third ruts, which occur roughly one to two months, respectively, after peak breeding.
These periods have one trait in common: There are only a few receptive does available, relative to the number of bucks. Even with an unbalanced buck:doe ratio, at such times there can be some competition for breeding privileges, resulting in at least two bucks intently focusing on one doe. This stands in sharp contrast to peak rut, when in a doe-heavy herd there are so many willing mates that the few bucks present need not squabble over them.
YOU NEED TO BE READY FOR ANYTHING
Because a breeding party is a highly fluid situation, if you should encounter one, be prepared to take a "make it up as you go along" approach. There's no way to know exactly what's about to happen, because the deer themselves don't know.
The participants have varying agendas. The "hot" doe at the center of it all instinctively wants to be bred, but perhaps not just yet -- and perhaps not by the buck hanging closest to her. If, as is typically the case, one or more of the bucks is young, his presence will infuriate any older bucks on the scene. And any unreceptive does/fawns caught up in the group are basically innocent bystanders that would rather be left alone by all of the bucks.
Yes, every deer is to a large extent focused on the other participants, and that can work to your advantage. But offsetting this is the reality that many eyes, ears and noses are present. As a result, your margin for error is hardly huge. At any moment, one of the deer could pick you off, putting all of them on alert. Likewise, one of the bucks could harass the doe into bolting, leading the party in a direction that offers you no shot.
North American Whitetall North American Whitetail is designed for the serious trophy hunter. It provides authoritative coverage of world-class whitetails, the latest approaches to deer management and advanced hunting techniques.