King Buck Controversy: Boone and Crockett Denies Possible World Record

The long awaited date with destiny for the King buck has come and gone, but the controversy of the "what if legend" will continue to surround this special deer. Boone and Crockett ruled today that the King buck would not be crowned the new world record typical buck like so many had expected.

After reconvening for a second look at the King buck, B&C scored the rack as 180 typical points or 217 5/8 non-typical points, depending on classification. The final decision will be left up to Johnny King as to how he wants the great buck remembered.

The official ruling on the King buck states that the questionable G-3's are in fact non-typical points and therefore the rack will be measured with considerable deductions, thus not able to claim the top spot in the record book. This is what so many have wanted, an official ruling by B&C that will stand for prosperity, but is this the correct outcome? Does this ruling do nothing more than take away some of the King buck's regal status by giving it such a low score? No longer will antler aficionados discuss the possible outcome or how wonderful it will be for the world record to be from south of the border again.

If only those beautiful G-3s had grown just a fraction of an inch wider apart. If they had, today would be a day of celebration for Johnny King and the entire whitetail world. Instead, the Milo Hansen buck of Saskatchewan will remain the reigning world record holder.

There will be many debates about such a controversial rack, and discussions as to why it took B&C so long to call this special measuring session in order to rule on the King buck. At the end of the day B&C has final say over how a buck will be remembered in the annals of history, and once again the King buck is likely to be known as the "what if legend" from Wisconsin.

What do you think about this final ruling?

More Industry


Getting to Know the National Deer Alliance

Bob Humphrey - May 04, 2017

In 2014, I was invited to attend the first North American Whitetail Summit. I thought it was


Deadly Determination: Hunting While Pregnant

Darron McDougal - December 27, 2017

Pregnancy can't stop a hardcore woman from capturing her fall 2017 deer goals. How many...


(VIDEO): Hunters Rescue Entangled Buck From Water

North American Whitetail Online Staff - November 15, 2013

If you hang around the outdoors long enough, you're bound to see some crazy things. That was

See More Industry

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.