Best Spots for Bowhunting New York Trophy Bucks

For whatever reason, New York doesn't get all that much publicity as a bowhunting hotspot. But this state has a long history of outstanding archery hunting — and it continues to produce plenty of exceptional whitetails every bow season.

New York has a bowhunter base of roughly a quarter-million participants, with a recent influx of younger archers having fueled a surge of interest. Dropping the minimum bowhunting age from 14 to 12 (which happened several years ago) has lured thousands of new hunters into the field.

Cathy Turner arrowed this 170 1/8-inch typical in western New York's Monroe County on Oct. 30, 2010. The monster field-dressed 200 pounds. Cathy is a former two-time Olympic gold medalist in speed skating, and she says shooting this buck brought a similar thrill.

Your first thought might be that one of the nation's most heavily populated states would have difficulty producing many big whitetails. Between hunting pressure and road traffic, how might a New York buck possibly live long enough to grow a 125-inch set of antlers?

As it turns out, there are pockets of relatively light hunting pressure here. And despite the number of vehicles, many bucks dodge bumpers long enough to end up in taxidermy shops instead of road ditches.

The two main "hot zones" for trophy bow bucks in New York both feature relatively light hunting pressure. But they're widely separated on the map and could hardly seem more different from each other. One of these pockets lies in the southeastern corner of the state, while the other is far to the west. These are the places that keep pumping out P&Y qualifiers. So if you're looking for a bragging-sized rack, pay close attention. History doesn't lie.

The counties in red — Westchester, Suffolk, Monroe, Livingston, Ontario and Wayne — lead New York in all-time Pope & Young whitetails. Trailing those in P&Y entries, but still well above average for the state, are the western counties shown in orange.

Westchester and Suffolk counties are well known for their huge bucks. Due to the amount of unhuntable land in these suburban counties just outside New York City, many bucks there get a chance to reach maturity.

If you can gain access to land near off-limits private estates and other such tracts, you have a very good chance of getting a shot at a trophy deer.

Westchester, just north of the city, leads the state in terms of all-time P&Y entries. However, Long Island's Suffolk County has come on strong of late and in fact leads all of New York in entries since 2010.

This area's high human population density and habitat stand in sharp contrast to what you'll find in some of the rural counties of western New York. Out west, concrete and pavement give way to varied forms of agriculture — orchards, vineyards, vegetable farms and dairies — and way more elbow room for deer and hunters alike. Orleans County, for instance, is home to only about 110 people per square mile, compared to Westchester's 2,200.

"The two main "hot zones" for trophy bow bucks in New York both feature relatively light hunting pressure. But they're widely separated on the map and could hardly seem more different from each other."

There's also light overall hunting pressure on deer, making for outstanding trophy prospects. That said, it's worth noting that some of the more developed parts of western New York also have turned out their share of big bucks.

Many bowhunters who hunt near Syracuse, Rochester, Buffalo and other regional cities have fine bow bucks on their walls. In these suburban enclaves, the deer hunting is perhaps more similar to what you'd find around NYC. Locate the right tract and you could be in business.

Any attempt to point fellow hunters to the "best" places risks offending those who hunt elsewhere and feel those locations are just as worthy of praise.

While the counties highlighted here and on the accompanying map have great track records, scattered pockets of solid trophy potential exist all over the state; a P&Y candidate could come from anywhere.

Chris Grant's 161 4/8-inch 10-pointer was taken in Orange County during the 2014 archery season. This area north of New York City has put 20 whitetails into the P&Y record book over the years.

So the recommendations made in this overview are simply a starting point for prospective trophy chasers. You'll need to do your own field reconnaissance to narrow down the very best spots for your situation — but rest assured, they're out there.

For more on New York's top bow bucks, visit New York State Big Buck Club. For details on trophy bow kills from around North America, check out Pope & Young Club.

More United States

United States

Hunting In Kentucky Offers Plenty To DIY Archers

Bernie Barringer - November 07, 2017

Kentucky abounds with deer-hunting opportunities, and many would consider it a sleeper state...

United States

The Top 10 Whitetail Spots for 2017

Bob Humphrey - May 31, 2017

You've waited, scrimped and saved and now can finally afford that that once-in-a-lifetime...

United States

The 10 Best Deer Hunting Spots for 2018

Bob Humphrey

Check out our expert's picks for the top 10 deer hunting destinations for 2018!

See More United States

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Temporary Price Reduction


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services


GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.