Should You Fill All Your Doe Tags?

Should You Fill All Your Doe Tags?

The year was 1978, and I was participating in a deer management seminar in Mississippi. Several of us “young” biologists were on the panel, and it came time for questions from the floor.

“How many does should we harvest this year?” a man asked.

A fellow panelist responded instantly, “Can you buy .30-06 cartridges in 55- gallon drums?”

The hunter’s face dropped as he sat down, shaking his head. While I shuddered at the flippant answer, I generally agreed with the basic thought. At that time, some hunting clubs along the Mississippi River had frightening densities as high as a whitetail per two acres. We had to take more does.


Back then, and for years afterwards, my view was that wildlife agencies hadn’t done a very good job of controlling whitetail populations. Without lowering numbers, such dire consequences as disease outbreaks and habitat damage were looming. Gradually, though, agencies began to take action, largely through increased doe harvest.


Is the approach we widely recommended in the 1970s still applicable in today’s deer world? Not necessarily. Whitetails are what we call a “K-adapted” species; that is, the population is controlled mostly by habitat. Yet a doe is biologically capable of contributing to an annual population increase as high as 150 percent, given good habitat conditions. Whitetails also are genetically programmed to saturate their range in as little as seven years.

Long ago, natural habitats were largely controlled by such factors as wildfires and severe weather, including tornados, hurricanes, blizzards and droughts. After a major disturbance, forests would undergo the natural process of succession. Bare ground gave way to weeds, grasses, shrubs and trees, producing large amounts of foods preferred by deer. The result was a shift from low fawn survival to high recruitment rates. A low-density deer herd rapidly became a high-density herd.

But within 7-10 years, the vegetation often grew beyond what we call the “deer zone” (from the ground up to 4 1/2 feet), shading out deer forage plants. Slowly, herd growth declined, ultimately returning to lower fawn survival and overall lower densities.

By 1900, in many places we had a landscape pretty much devoid of natural ecosystems. Forests had been cleared or destroyed by wildfires, and prairies had become fields of cereal grains or cattle pastures. Market and subsistence hunting had reduced deer numbers to the often-quoted but unsubstantiated “fewer than 500,000.”


Restoration efforts were enthusiastically accepted by hunters and landowners, and within 50 years, they enjoyed remarkable success. Unfortunately, at the time professionals and conservationists hadn’t yet given much thought to managing deer, only restoring them. The result was a runaway train.

But a lot has changed in 40 years. We’re learning that what was true in 1978 might not be so workable in 2018. At the time of that Mississippi meeting, deer conformed to what we commonly called a “compensatory” response to deer removal. I gave a paper to another gathering of deer biologists, outlining a theory that there’s a “sweet spot” of deer production at a population density of one-half what the habitat will carry. I adopted the term “maximum sustained yield” after a paper presented by a population ecologist.

About a year later, Dr. Dale McCullough published The George Reserve Deer Herd, which presented Michigan data supporting this theory. He showed that if you removed a large number of does from a herd that was hanging on at carrying capacity, there would be a compensatory bump in fawn recruitment. This led to the mentality espoused by the biologist recommending buying ammo in 55-gallon drums.


But as time passed, I began to question the long-term sustainability of this management approach. Because other controlling forces were appearing.

Not so long ago, deer biologists considered the coyote basically just a nuisance. I recall a well-known biologist at an early meeting of the Southeast Deer Study Group (an annual gathering of biologists) saying coyotes weren’t a problem. As of 10 years ago, he was publicly calling for coyotes’ heads! The predator had by then spread to the Atlantic Coast and northward into New England.

Meanwhile, public sentiment increasingly favored protection of not just coyotes but also bobcats, bears, mountain lions and wolves. Today, these species are increasing at an alarming rate. Scientific studies often report a “negligible” impact of a given predator, but the combined impact of the full suite of predators can be staggering.

In the U.S., the Wilderness Act ushered in a new philosophy in forest management. This hands-off approach caused some productive deer habitats to mature into non-productive ecosystems. Furthermore, deer themselves were having a huge impact. Years of over-browsing had all but eliminated the best native plants that had led to the population boom. The emergence of industrial farming using herbicide-resistant crops also contributed to lost deer productivity.

Many deer diseases are “density-dependent,” meaning their impact is directly related to population density. High populations were ripe for the appearance and spread of many diseases, most notably the viral hemorrhagic diseases EHD and bluetongue. Bacterial diseases also were beginning to be commonly seen in wild deer. (The much-feared CWD is not density-dependent.)

At first, whitetail biologists looked at hemorrhagic diseases as “natural,” because they’d been common in Southern herds with no apparent long-term effects. (EHD also has been known since the late 1950s in New Jersey and Michigan.) But more recently, new strains have appeared, caused by a rearrangement of the genes of an exotic strain with those of a native form. Such mutated viruses already have killed thousands of deer, if not millions.

Lastly, humans have had additional direct impacts. The number of whitetails killed annually by vehicles is equal to or greater than the annual hunter take. Increases in season lengths and bag limits have also substantially increased intentional deer mortality.

Since 2000, whitetail harvests and populations have fallen by almost 20 percent. For example, in parts of northern Minnesota and Wisconsin, increased predation, deteriorating habitat and over-harvest encouraged by longer seasons and higher bag limits have caused deer numbers to fall so drastically some hunters have given up. The old ways no longer work.

Harvest decisions must be based on data acquired locally, which few wildlife agencies have done. The Deer Management Assistance Program models developed years ago by Drs. David Guynn and Harry Jacobson need to be employed across the landscape. Biologists working cooperatively with local hunters and landowners is the best way to manage. A site-specific plan must be developed and accepted by local people, or it will never work.

Doe management is a fine-tuning process. Implement a conservative strategy, measure the response of the deer and habitat, then tweak your plan in response to what you learn. Each herd is site-specific, so doe bag limits for large geographic areas should be avoided. Unfortunately, many agencies still have problems accepting that.

Even if your wildlife agency authorizes a high bag limit on does, there’s no law saying you must kill that many! Landowners and hunters know more about what’s going on locally than do biologists at state headquarters. However, we must make decisions based on what’s really going on, not on what we wish were going on. That can mean refraining from shooting a doe even though it’s late in deer season and your freezer is far from full.

Management now is more challenging than ever. Faced with declining hunter numbers, wildlife agencies and biologists must give up on old dogma. Hopefully, young biologists will take up the challenge, just as my generation did back in the 1970s.

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Recommended Articles

See More Recommendations

Popular Videos

North American Whitetail - South of the Border

North American Whitetail - South of the Border

Dr. James Kroll and Pat Hogan head south of the border in pursuit of whitetails in old Mexico.

Deer Dog: Shed Conditioning

Deer Dog: Shed Conditioning

Jeremy Moore talks about the importance of your deer dog's physical conditioning.

Deer Factory: Northern Climate Warm-Season Food Plots

Deer Factory: Northern Climate Warm-Season Food Plots

Dr. James Kroll and Pat Hogan discuss warm-season food plots on this deer factory in Minnesota.

Illinois Muzzleloader Whitetail Hunt

Illinois Muzzleloader Whitetail Hunt

G.O. Heath is hunting with his muzzleloader in Illinois.

See More Popular Videos

Trending Articles

Understanding what deer eat and how they adjust their diets to meet changing nutritional requirements will not only increase your chances of harvesting a good buck, but also your enjoyment of whitetail hunting. Land Management

What Do Deer Eat?

Dr. James C. Kroll

Understanding what deer eat and how they adjust their diets to meet changing nutritional...

Even snow-white deer are fairly common in comparison to those that are abnormally dark in color. Deer Behavior & Facts

Rarest Whitetails Of All?

Gordon Whittington - September 22, 2010

Even snow-white deer are fairly common in comparison to those that are abnormally dark in...

Here's a look at some of the new deer rifles from SHOT Show 2020! Guns

Best New Deer Hunting Rifles for 2020

Lynn Burkhead - January 29, 2020

Here's a look at some of the new deer rifles from SHOT Show 2020!

We'll explain which supplements whitetails can obtain in the field, and the best ways to provide them with the ones they can't. Off-Season

Which Minerals Do Deer Need?

Dr. James C. Kroll

We'll explain which supplements whitetails can obtain in the field, and the best ways to...

See More Trending Articles

More Conservation

With 'zombie deer' headlines going viral and Chronic Wasting Disease suddenly making front-page news, Dr. Deer sounded off on the topic. Conservation

The Truth About Zombie Deer & A CWD Cure

Lynn Burkhead - February 22, 2019

With 'zombie deer' headlines going viral and Chronic Wasting Disease suddenly making...

Thumb through a western South Dakota hunting atlas and you'll find a splatter of colors showing Conservation

History of School Lands for Public Hunting

Spencer Neuharth - September 19, 2018

Thumb through a western South Dakota hunting atlas and you'll find a splatter of colors showing

Not long ago, had you walked into the average gun shop or feed store and claimed, Conservation

Whitetails at the Crossroads: Have Whitetail Numbers Declined?

Gordon Whittington - September 16, 2014

Not long ago, had you walked into the average gun shop or feed store and claimed, "Whitetails...

An Iowa hunter has been keeping tabs on this unique doe for years. Conservation

Iowa's 3-Legged Doe

Gordon Whittington

An Iowa hunter has been keeping tabs on this unique doe for years.

See More Conservation

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

PREVIEW THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get Digital Access.

All North American Whitetail subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now